Monday, March 25, 2013

THIRD STREET: HATCHER'S MASTER PLAN

Hatcher giving us the finger on Third Street

   
     Below are the some 220 Portsmouth  properties owned by Neal Hatcher and associates as of this date (3/25/2013). Some dozen of those properties,  indicated in red below, are located on 3rd Street. However, because of front corporations, the auditor's list of Hatcher properties on Third and other streets is far from complete. For example it does not include the dozen or so SSU student dormitories that Hatcher owns, through  Campus View Associates, which I have listed below, those on Third Street highlighted in red.

     The closing of Third Street is part of Hatcher's Master Plan for the university. I expect the university to incorporate 4th Street in the future, as part of that same plan. He already owns student dormitories on 4th Street, and he  has also been buying property east of the SSU campus, the lebensraum, as it could be called, which is the direction the university will grow. Under the arrangement Hatcher has worked out with the university and city, the financial risks involved in the expansion of the campus are borne by the city and university, and ultimately by tax payers. If the occupancy rate of his dormitories falls below 92 percent, he will be reimbursed for the difference. And when his dormitories begin to age, and maintenance costs rise, he or his heirs, will be able to exercise the provision of the contract that allows him to sell them to a private party or to the university. As a developer, by buying property cheap and selling it dear,  Hatcher has made a fortune capitalizing on Portsmouth's chronic poverty. He would not have been able to do it if he did not have the politicians in city government in his pocket. As long as the city government remains corrupt, Hatcher and people like him will continue to capitalize on the city's chronic poverty. As in many other streets in the city, Hatcher is giving the citizens of Portsmouth the finger on Third Street.

Further reading: "Student Housing Shenanigans" (click here).





Current Owner 
Parcel ID 
Address 
Legal 
300203000
1412 GALLIA ST
GLOVER WHOLE 35 X 150 LOT 4
312267000
1400 COLES AVE
LOTS 11 THRU 19 35 THRU 48 +
290689000
7TH ST
CITY PT VAC VINE-SPRUCE ALLEY
300566000
1242 4TH ST
H. WALLER E PT 30 X 107FT 3IN
300441000
1326 4TH ST
GLOVER TRACT 66-67 49 X 111
300791000
612 GLOVER ST
GLOVER MID PT 20FT 10IN X 128F
300392000
1400 GALLIA ST
GLOVER WHOLE 93FT 4IN X 100/13
290344000
901 9TH ST
NOEL #2 WH 41'5" X 123 LOT 9
330046000
2817 WILLOW WAY
FOREST PARK WHOLE 62 X 120 LOT
290103000
409 CHILLICOTHE ST
CITY N PT 33 X 165 LOT 135-13
311305000
1062 28TH ST
HERMANN LOT 32 40X131.2 + NOEL
330159000
0 DORMAN DR
DORMAN TERRACE 150 X 112.52 LO
310798000
1517 FRANKLIN AVE
HIGH WHOLE 37 X 120 LOT 116
311233000
1249 COLES BLVD
RTS 21-1-8 FRAC N SIDE OF BLVD
330373000
2109 GRANT ST
MOUND WHOLE 35 X 136FT 3IN LOT
300576000
1010 4TH ST
P B + S W 1/2 32 X 107FT 3IN L
301172000
944 4TH ST
P B + S E 1/2 30 X 107FT 3IN L
300295000
1223 3RD ST
WALLER EST. PT LOT 4-5 41FT
310231000
1227 COLES BLVD
JOHNSON WHOLE 40 X 184 LOT 7
330571000
1602 FRANKLIN AVE
HIGHLAND FRONT PT 33FT 3IN X 6
311831000
1611 HIGHLAND AVE
LOREN W 1/2 25FT 9IN X 110FT
321481000
1717 11TH ST
TURLEY E 1/2 LOT 25 ALL LOT 24
301245000
833 10TH ST
BARR E 1/2, 25 X 132 LOT 173
301064000
1207 3RD ST
WALLER EST. PT LOT 5 25 X 1
300793000
1130 10TH ST
BARR W 1/2 35 X 132 LOT 91
301089000
119 OFFNERE ST
THOMPSON PT 22FT 11 1/2 IN X 1
301079000
416 GAY ST
CITY N PT LOT 580, REAR LOT 60
301479000
0 GALLIA ST
P B S 30/19.01 X 111.05/67.67/
320651000
1522 JACKSON ST
DAWSON E PT LOT 10, W PT LOT 1
300642000
1316 3RD ST
THOMPSON PT EA 56FT 10 1/2IN X
300846000
920 JOHN ST
BARR MID PT W PT LOT 88 MID PT
332151000
1909 TIMMONDS AVE
TIMMONDS WHOLE 37 X 124 LOT 17
330644000
1706 HIGHLAND AVE
HIGHLAND W. PT. 32FT 6IN X 120
301119000
118 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON PT 22FT 3IN X 132 LOT
300339000
928 JOHN ST
BARR N PT 27 X 105 LOT 87-88
301216000
2ND ST
THOMPSON MID PT 50 X 150 LOT 7
332719000
3124 NORTH HILL RD
INDIAN HILLS SUB 73.04 X 160.0
310336000
1635 ROBINSON AVE
LOREN PT.EA. 34FT 10IN X 144 L
300246000
937 3RD ST
P B + S PT EACH 34 X 123FT 9IN
320148000
1712 CHARLES ST
NORWOOD WHOLE 35 X 100 LOT 66
300543000
1426 3RD ST
THOMPSON E PT 32 X 117 LOT 80-
331000000
1519 HIGH ST
MOUND WHOLE 36FT 6IN X 115 LOT
300019000
1424 3RD ST
THOMPSON PT EA 32 X 117 LOT
321824000
1716 CHARLES ST
NORWOOD WHOLE 35 X 100 LOT 64
300940000
1015 GALLIA ST
SALTER ADD. E. PT LOT 7 W. PT
300177000
121 OFFNERE ST
THOMPSON MID PT S PT 27FT 6 1/
301244000
319 OFFNERE ST
GLOVER TRACT 74 37FT 1IN X
300479000
13 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON PT EACH 33 X 124 LOT
321496000
1708 12TH ST
TURLEY PT EA 29FT 11IN X 131FT
310838000
1662 HIGHLAND AVE
ON HIGHLAND AVE. 21 X 110 RTS
300691002
1010 GALLIA ST
COMMUNITY RE-INVESTMENT 15 YR
321687000
1661 11TH ST
TURLEY WHOLE 35 X 130 LOT 30
300475000
927 3RD ST
P B + S W 1/2 26FT 6IN X 123FT
330031000
2006 KINNEYS LN
MICK. IMP. CO. WHOLE LOT 13 W
300440000
1109 9TH ST
BARR W PT 37 X 132 LOT 77
301081000
1418 6TH ST
GLOVER WHOLE 35 X 128FT 4IN LO
320163000
1702 12TH ST
TURLEY W PT 29FT11IN X 131FT 2
301280000
1305 2ND ST
THOMPSON E. PT. LOT 73 E. PT.
300511000
9 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON WHOLE LOT 34 S PTLOT
300643000
3 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON PT 46FT 3IN X 109FT 3
320257000
1523 JACKSON ST
DAMARIN PT 25 X 171.25 LOT 95
273456000
226 WARREN AVE
COLES PARK WHOLE EA 150 X 150
300900000
1115 9TH ST
BARR W 1/2, 35 X 132 LOT 76
322073000
1742 11TH ST
HUTCHINS WHOLE 34 X 146 LOT 12
300319000
1321 2ND ST
THOMPSON E PT 60 X 150 LOT 70-
301300000
940 GALLIA ST
P B + S W 1/2 30 X 184 LOT 77
300360000
1165 9TH ST
HUTCHINS PT. OF LOT 54 23FT 6I
300113000
940 4TH ST
P B + S W 1/2, 30 X 107FT 3IN
321744000
1721 11TH ST
HUTCHINS WHOLE 35 X 130 LOT 10
321220000
1003 CLAY ST
SKELTON FRONT PT. 67.88 X 102
332002000
1822 GRANDVIEW AVE
R + H WHOLE 32 X 120 LOT 7
300270000
920 FINDLAY ST
BARR N PT + MID PT 33FT 8IN X
300688000
920 8TH ST
BARR W 1/2 27FT 6IN X 107FT 3I
300845000
924 JOHN ST
BARR SO. PT 39 X 105 LOT 87-88
300143000
314 WALLER ST
WALLER LOT 19 TERRY EXT PT LOT
300425000
914 8TH ST
BARR MID PT 27FT 6IN X 107FT 3
300382000
17 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON MID PT. 21FT 5IN X 12
320637000
1748 11TH ST
HUTCHINS WHOLE 35FT 6IN X 146
300763000
114 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON S 1/2 33 X 132 LOT 59
310372000
1225 COLES BLVD
JOHNSON WHOLE 40 X 184 LOT 6
301157000
122 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON PT 22FT 1 1/2IN X 132
273458000
0 WARREN AVE
COLES PARK WHOLE 50 X 150 LOT
300649000
415 SINTON AVE
P B + S N PT 34FT 5IN X 32 LOT
300523001
1120 4TH ST
COMMUNITY RE-INVESTMENT 15 YEA
300169000
1012 4TH ST
P B + S E 1/2 32 X 107FT 3IN L
300086000
108 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON PT EA 26 X 132 LOT 51
301103000
922 8TH ST
BARR E 1/2 41FT 3IN X 107FT 3I
300667000
1105 9TH ST
BARR PART 32FT 6IN X 132 LOT 7
300577000
938 GALLIA ST
P B + S E PT 40 X 178 LOT 76
321645000
1530 3RD ST
BANK WHOLE 40 X 166FT 9IN LOT
300691001
0 BOND ST
P B & S S 100 OF LOT 79-80 S 1
330787000
1815 SUMMIT ST
R + H WHOLE 32 X 120 LOT 23
310588000
1201 24TH ST
SUNNYSIDE W.PT. 35FT 6IN X 203
301116000
825 10TH ST
BARR W 1/2 25 X 132 LOT 174
320962000
1531 3RD ST
BANK ALL LOT 17, PT LOT 18,
273672000
29 STOCKHAM HILL RD
HILLSDALE PT 91-92 42X107 68/8
300031000
934 4TH ST
P B + S W 1/2, 30 X 107FT 3IN
300662000
1229 3RD ST
H. WALLER MID PT 30 X 107 LOT
300149000
1208 4TH ST
WALLER EST. PT LOT 5 29FT 6
320961000
1527 3RD ST
BANK WHOLE 30 X 111FT 9IN LOT
301246000
614 GLOVER ST
GLOVER N PT 35 X 128FT 4IN LOT
300563000
918 JOHN ST
BARR S PT OF EACH 33 X 140 LOT
332389000
1903 ROBINSON AVE
HOME PT EA 24 X 111FT 8IN LOT
332725000
0 NORTH HILL RD
INDIAN HILL SUBD PT NE COR 20
331126000
1611 GRANDVIEW AVE
H + S S PT 33 X 133FT 6IN LOT
300211000
318 CHILLICOTHE ST
CITY N PT 18FT 2IN X 130 LOT 5
330745000
1818 GRANDVIEW AVE
R + H WHOLE 32 X 120 LOT 6
300550000
1220 4TH ST
WALLER EST PT. LOT 5, 50 X
300660000
948 4TH ST
P B + S PT E 1/2 30 X 107FT 3I
300672000
11TH ST
PT VAC ALLEY MORGAN PT LOT 113
301282000
1224 4TH ST
H WALLER WHOLE 38 X 107FT 3IN
300350000
423 WALLER ST
B + G PT EA 55 X 125FT 4IN LOT
300139000
1316 4TH ST
GLOVER TRACT 63 12 X 109
300710000
1316 4TH ST
GLOVER TRACT 63 24FT X 111F
300851000
1415 6TH ST
GLOVER PT EA. 40 X 66FT 6IN LO
330507000
1524 HIGH ST
MOUND 36FT 6IN X 115 LOT 149
300691000
1010 GALLIA ST
P B & S N PT LOT 79-80 N PT E
300651000
2ND ST
THOMPSON E PT 30 X 104 LOT 63-
301239000
1004 4TH ST
P B + S W PT 36 X 107FT 3IN LO
300042000
11 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON MID PT 49FT 8IN X 124
311079000
1220 JOHNSON ST
JOHNSON WHOLE 40 X 157FT 6IN L
321060000
1746 11TH ST
HUTCHINS WHOLE 34 X 146 LOT 12
300871000
1124 10TH ST
BARR W PT 30 X 132 LOT 90
300675000
1018 11TH ST
MORGAN PT EA + VAC ALLEY 115.7
300941000
1021 GALLIA ST
SALTER ADD. ALL LOT 9 E PT L
301275000
1147 9TH ST
HUTCHINS W PT LOT 48 ALL LOT 4
300537000
1114 10TH ST
BARR N PT, E PT 35/25 X 99 LOT
300245000
902 8TH ST
BARR WEST PT 50 X 107FT 3IN LO
300079000
821 10TH ST
BARR WHOLE 50 X 132 LOT 175
291046000
2129 ARGONNE
TRAILTON WHOLE 40 X 150 LOT 47
310824000
1245 COLES BLVD
FRAC. N. S. BLVD. 80 X 269 RTS
301047000
1128 10TH ST
BARR E PT 20 X 132 LOT 90
300523000
1116 4TH ST
RIGGS + MEANS & PB S PT LOT 4
300259000
410 GAY ST
CITY MID PT 38 X 64 LOT 580
320642000
1712 12TH ST
TURLEY PT EA. 29FT 11IN X 131F
300135000
906 8TH ST
BARR E PT 32FT 6IN X 107FT 3IN
321672000
1718 12TH ST
TURLEY PT EA 29FT 11IN X 131FT
321031000
1523 3RD ST
DAMARIN WHOLE 31 X 111FT 9IN L
300658000
102
3 4TH ST
P B + S S PT E 1/2 32 X 91 LOT
321598000
1525 JACKSON ST
BANK WHOLE 30 X 166FT 9IN LOT
300653000
1406 2ND ST
THOMPSON MID 30 X 120 LOT 63-6
300652000
2 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON W 27 X 120 LOT 63-67
320383000
1507 4TH ST
DAMARIN WHOLE 35 X 111FT 9IN L
300020000
946 4TH ST
P B + S W 1/2, 30 X 107FT 3IN
300477000
605 OFFNERE ST
GLOVER FRONT PT, 40FT 1IN X 88
321248000
1553 6TH ST
MADDOCK WHOLE 25 X 111FT 8IN L
300074000
829 10TH ST
BARR E 1/2 LOT 174 W 1/2 LOT
271496000
0 LARKIN ST
HILLSDALE AMEND PT 31.8 X 66 L
301004000
923 FINDLAY ST
BARR WH EACH 112 X 115 LOT 130
301218000
1014 4TH ST
P B + S W PT 35 X 107FT 3IN LO
301208000
1315 3RD ST
GLOVER TRACT 89 29.56 X 98
300157000
945 4TH ST
P B + S WH. EACH 240FT X 164FT
320549000
1662 12TH ST
TURLEY WHOLE 35 X 131FT 2IN LO
332727000
3118 NORTH HILL RD
INDIAN HILL SUB 68.18 X 180.07
301056000
10TH ST
BARR MID PT 20 X 132 LOT 90
300626000
1006 4TH ST
P B + S E PT 28 X 107FT 3IN LO
310460000
1245 COLES BLVD
JOHNSON WHOLE 80 X 184 LOT 9-
310013000
0 ALTAMONT AVE
FRAC N. S. BLVD. 20 X 40 RTS 2
300702000
8 UNION ST
THOMPSON N 1/2 33 X 124 LOT 33
321528000
0 CLAY ST
SKELTON + VAC. ALLEY REAR PT.
301007000
918 FINDLAY ST
BARR S PT MID 33FT 8IN X 64 LO
310821000
1245 COLES BLVD
JOHNSON W 62 X 157'6" 54.7 X
300419000
936 4TH ST
P B + S E 1/2, 30 X 107FT 3IN
301002000
1411 6TH ST
GLOVER E PT 34FT 4IN X 121 LOT
332694000
0 INDIAN DR
INDIAN HILLS (SUB OF LOT 56) 2
300565000
21 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON WHOLE 66 X 124 LOT 46
300140000
1318 4TH ST
GLOVER TRACT 64 30 X 109
310672000
2612 SUNRISE AVE
HENRY GALLENSTEIN WHOLE 51.88/
300536000
1116 10TH ST
BARR W 1/2, 35 X 132 LOT 89
320859000
212 OFFNERE ST
DAMARIN MID PT 35 X 109FT 6IN
320015000
1658 12TH ST
TURLEY WH 35 X 131'2" LOT 16 M
300513001
4 UNION ST
THOMPSON 33 X 62.17 FT. AC. .0
312179000
1231 COLES BLVD
JOHNSON WHOLE 40 X 184 LOT 8
300672001
1026 FINDLAY ST
BARR L 106 MAP 24-001
331257000
1816 GRANDVIEW AVE
R + H WHOLE 32 X 120 LOT 5
300821000
916 FINDLAY ST
BARR S PT 33 X 64 LOT 83
300508000
14 UNION ST
THOMPSON N PT 33 X 124 LOT 37
311397000
1253 COLES BLVD
FRAC N SIDE OF BLVD. 60 X 120
301040000
1113 9TH ST
BARR E PT 33 X 132 LOT 77
300904000
1401 6TH ST
GLOVER W PT 30 X 121 LOT 14-15
320293000
210 OFFNERE ST
DAMARIN PT EA 35 X 109FT 6IN L
300443000
817 10TH ST
BARR WHOLE 40 X 132 LOT 176
300949000
614 GLOVER ST
GLOVER PT EACH 25 X 128FT 4IN
301241000
837 10TH ST
BARR E 1/2 25 X 132 LOT 172
300480000
19 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON N PT 21FT 5IN X 124 L
300967000
833 11TH ST
BARR WH. LOT 193 W. PT. LOT 19
300709000
1312 4TH ST
GLOVER TRACT 62 42FT 9IN X
300616000
1412 2ND ST
THOMPSON MID PT 30 X 120 LOT 6
301215000
1311 2ND ST
THOMPSON PT EACH 50 X 150 LOT
300172000
8 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON ALL LOT 35-39-43-47 W
301248000
1420 2ND ST
THOMPSON MID PT 45 X 120 LOT 6
312043000
1214 JOHNSON ST
JOHNSON WHOLE 80 X 157FT 6IN L
300352000
120 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON PT EA 22FT 2IN X 132
300034000
1235 3RD ST
H. WALLER PT EA 28 X 107FT 3IN
300542000
1005 4TH ST
PB+S ALL LOT 68+69+70 PT LOT
301042000
1416 2ND ST
THOMPSON E PT LOT 63-67 W PT L
300670000
1120 10TH ST
BARR E 1/2, 35 X 132 LOT 89
321788000
218 OFFNERE ST
DAMARIN N PT EA 35 X 139FT 6IN
300399000
1025 9TH ST
BARR WHOLE 64 X 132 LOT 79
290911000
713 6TH ST
CITY E 1/4 41FT 2IN X 107FT 3I
300513000
0 WHEELING ST
THOMPSON S 1/2 33 X 62 LO
300764000
110 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON MID PT 26 X 132 LOT 5
290558000
2310 ARGONNE
ARLINGTON WHOLE 34FT 6IN X 110
300762000
112 GLOVER ST
THOMPSON N PT 28 X 132 LOT 55
290176000
2312 ARGONNE
ARLINGTON WHOLE 35 X 110FT 1IN
290345000
907 29TH ST
NOEL #2 WHOLE 38FT 6IN X 123 L
301297000
918 8TH ST
BARR W. PT.LOT 621 E. PT. LOT
301159000
411 SINTON AVE
P B + S S PT 39FT 2IN X 32 LOT
311762000
1044 NOEL DR
BLD HTS. WH EACH IRR. 225.69 X
321897000
1554 CHARLES ST
LAND ON JACKSON AVE. .20 A. RT
300388000
910 8TH ST
BARR W 1/2 41FT 3IN X 107FT 3I
300956000
815 10TH ST
BARR E. PT. W. PT. 40 X 132 LO
320166000
1644 6TH ST
GREEN W PT, 22 X 111FT9IN LOT
300742000
1129 9TH ST
BARR W 1/2 35 X 132 LOT 74
301053001
11TH ST
BARR PT 25 X 132 LOT 188 MAP
301162000
1017 GAY ST
BARR WH 100 X 132 LOT 189-190
310650000
22ND ST
WILLIAMSON REAR PT. 35.9 X 2
310649000
2208 SCIOTO TRAIL
RIVERVIEW PART 55 X 142.41 L
310087000
2220 SCIOTO TRAIL
RIVERVIEW N PT OF EACH 140FT 8


Campus View Associates

Current Owner Parcel ID Address Legal 
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATED LLC300897000500 3RD STP B + S 103 X 123FT 9IN LOT
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3001710001131 4TH STGREEN PT LOT 3 WH LOT 2 PT LOT
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC300494000800 3RD STKEHOE 115.18FT X 107FT 3 IN
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3012250011135 3RD STCOMMUNITY REINVESTMENT START 2
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3005620011117 4TH STCOMMUNITY REINVESTMENT START 2
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC300002000417 WALLER STB + G WHOLE 28 X 125FT 3IN
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3002680001106 4TH STP B + S ALL LOT 10 W PT LOT 9
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC300283000420 WALLER STTERRY S PT EACH 30 X 110 LOT 1
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3011760001126 4TH STRIGGS + MEANS LOT 2-3-PT LOT
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3008760001201 4TH STTERRY W PT 60 X 135 LOT 18
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3001370001142 4TH STKEHOE W PT 33FT 1IN X 107FT 3I
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3004160001106 4TH STP B + S PT EA 45 X 107FT 3IN L
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3010370001025 3RD STP B + S ALL LOT 49 & E PT LOT
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3008050001141 4TH STGREEN PT LOT 1 13.5X140 B &
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC300257000600 3RD STP B +S PT LOT 46-47 90 FT X

CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3005620001121 4TH STGREEN 113.50 X 140 PT LOT 5 WH
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3010520011109 3RD STCOMMUNITY REINVESTMENT 10 YEAR
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3006440001140 4TH STKEHOE WHOLE 50FT 1IN X 107FT 3
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC300170000416 WALLER STTERRY S PT 30 X 110 LOT 14
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3001170011005 3RD STCOMMUNITY REINVESTMENT 15 YRS
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3002790001134 4TH STKEHOE WHOLE 27 X 107FT 3IN LOT
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC301052000400 3RD STP B + S LOT 48 86 X 123FT 9
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC301202000413 WALLER STB + G WHOLE 28 X 125FT 3IN LOT
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC300721000943 3RD STP B S 28 X 123FT 9IN LOT 53-54
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3004940011145 3RD STCOMMUNITY REINVESTMENT START 2
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC301225000700 3RD STPB&S PT LOT 46 KEHOE LOT 5 11
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC300117000100-200 3RD STP B + S PT LOT 50 WHOLE LOT 51
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3012620001026 4TH STP B + S E PT LOT 64 AND ALL LO
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3012920011011 3RD STCOMMUNITY REINVESTMENT 15 YRS
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3002570011123 3RD STCOMMUNITY REINVESTMENT 10 YEAR

CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC301065000949 3RD STP B + S E PT 52 X 123FT 9IN LO
CAMPUS VIEW ASSOCIATES LLC3003400001130 4TH STP B + S WHOLE 50 X 107FT 3IN L

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Kiwanis Playground: Deathtrap for Tots?


The huge Copper Beech hardwood tree that crashed upon the Kiwanis playground



     Frank Lewis has outdone himself in shamelessness in his report in today’s  online Portsmouth Daily Times on the huge tree falling on the Kiwanis playground (click here). Because he is so skillful in covering up the crookedness of Portsmouth, Lewis could work for a hundred years for the PDT and he would never be fired or made to feel unwelcome as editors and reporters have in the past. He spends a good part of his story providing John Johnson, the president of the Portsmouth Kiwanis Club, and Kiwanis Ohio District Governor Donald Parker, with the opportunity for taking bows for the Kiwanians for the wonderful work they did in building “this wonderful playground,” “this world renowned playground.” What chutzpah! What a crock! The truth is the playground was and is a potential deathtrap for tots, not only because of falling trees but also because of the heavy vehicular traffic that swirls around it. 
     The city and the Kiwanis Club were warned about the potential consequences of how and where the playground was built, and they can thank whatever gods may be, or their lucky stars, that one or more children was not killed or badly injured when the tree fell. Surveying a bench the tree had obliterated, Jack Tackett of the Portsmouth City Service Department is quoted by Lewis as saying, euphemistically, “If somebody had been sitting on that bench they would have been in trouble. Would have been in trouble? They probably would have been dead. If only one child had been killed or injured, the city and Kiwanis could have been sued. Kiwanis’s claim that they now have no legal responsibility for the playground overlooks their culpability in this project from the start.  
     The real heroes in this mess is the couple who called everybody’s attention, including my own, to the problem of the rootless trees. Naturally, they were viewed as trouble makers, as what Steve Hayes of WNXT calls CAVE people, that is, Citizens Against Virtually Everything, including apparently deathtraps for tots. That’s how critics of the city are treated by the local media, as cave people.
     For my side of the story, read my 2009 post, “The Kiwanis Playground: The Hole Truth” (click here). Also read “Burning the Midnight Oil,” my 2009 post on Mayor Kalb’s email answer to my open records request for official documents related to the playground agreement between the city and the Kiwanis Club (click here). That was the email in which Kalb called me “a worthless piece of shit” and worse, the email that went viral. My blog crashed when the number of hits to “Burning the Midnight Oil” approached 450,000 in 48 hours. For the  country and the world, Kalb may have confirmed the worst stereotype of  the ugly American, if not the ignorant redneck. The world was astonished:  “What kind of a city would have such a crude ignoramus as mayor?” 
Kalb supplied me with an undated document that I suspected had been produced after the fact. I strongly suspected that the playground had been built without proper authorization, which would have made the whole project  a violation of Ohio law. I challenged both the city and Kiwanis to say that the written agreement was drawn up and signed before the project was begun. I got no answer from Kalb.  I visited the then president of the Portsmouth Kiwanis Club. I went with someone who knew Dr. Hamm-LaValley, who assured me the doctor of dentistry was an honorable woman. I was prepared to drop the whole matter if Dr. LaValley had an explanation of why the letter she signed was not dated, but she declined to talk to me. Immediately below also is a previous letter of intent, signed and dated 18 December, 2008, under the official Kiwanis letterhead. Below that is a copy of the undated agreement letter, signed by Dr. LaValley, which I suspect is undated because it was written after, perhaps well after construction of the playground began. That may be why it has a faux letterhead and is not written on either city of Portsmouth or on official Kiwanis stationary:

Dated playground letter of intent with Kiwanis letterhead
Undated Kiwanis letter of agreement with stark letterhead.


Finally, when the playground was dedicated, I wrote an open letter to the children of Portsmouth about the playground, trying to explain the controversy (click here).




Saturday, March 16, 2013

GOP: Gay Old Party?

rivervices.blogspot.com

Yesterday, Ohio Senator Rob Portman surprised almost  everybody, but especially conservative Republicans, by announcing his support of same-sex marriage. He changed his mind after his twenty-year-old son  told him a few years back that he was gay. Some Ohio Republicans were a little uneasy about Portman’s sexuality when he was mentioned as a possible vice president candidate, which of course was before he announced his support of same sex unions. Portman was perceived to be too low-key and  deferential, and he was an Ivy League graduate (Dartmouth). Among his incriminating activities? He likes to go hiking and he kept a kayak in his office in Washington.  His gay son is an undergraduate at YaleNot your NASCAR type. More your Log Cabin Republican type. But who can be sure there arent gays at the Indianapolis 500, and that there wont be a Nellies for NASCAR someday.
 There are deep divisions within the Republican Party, divisions that are growing wider each news cycle. Since he has already caved on Obamacare, who knows what liberal new  proposal Ohio’s Republican governor John Kasich is going to come up with in an attempt to prove he’s not a  Stone Age Republican. There is now a segment of the GOP that is getting so liberal that some liberal Democrats worry they are being outflanked on the left. It would be even less surprising  than Portmans switch if  Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine, hoping to get back his Senate seat, drops his tough guy Jimmy Cagney impersonation (yes, that’s what that is), announces he is gay,  and  supports same sex marriage. 

Bi-political Homosexual

The Portsmouth politician that may benefit most from the growing acceptance of gays is  city council member Kevin W. Johnson, whose Democratic affiliation presents little problem since he is bi-political, just the kind of bipartisanship that can help reduce  the paralyzing polarity of American politics. He has the strong backing of not only Democratic but also some Republican power brokers in Portsmouth. When a putatively pro-Johnson flyer was widely distributed during the last race for the First Ward seat on the city council, I assumed it was the work of the drug-dealing pimp who was the First Ward incumbent on the city council, or some of his supporters. I  assumed it was a homophobic hoax perpetrated by the pimp, who was as notoriously heterosexual as Johnson was openly homosexual. But because public opinion has shifted so much it  is possible, though still very unlikely, that the flyer was genuine. But in the seismic political and sexual shifts that are taking place, you cant be sure about anything.

Not long after taking his seat on the city council, Johnson strengthened his political position in Portsmouth by pushing a  primary ballot proposal to change the city charter from the mayoral to the city manager form of government. The proposal passed, but I think it would have failed in a general election because Portsmouth had already tried the city manager form of government and concluded it was even worse than the mayoral form, which it voted to return to. Why did Johnson want to get rid of the mayoral form of government? In part possibly because he wanted to get rid of the African-American mayor, David Malone, who is a hypocritical philandering evangelical preacher who denounced Johnson’s effort to get the city council to pass a resolution endorsing same sex unions. Malone believes homosexuality is the abomination that the Bible insists it is. Malone was appointed mayor when the first female mayor, Jane Murray, who challenged the monkey-business-as-usual tradition in Portsmouth, was recalled in a campaign that was led by the former Portsmouth police chief, the heavy-drinking Tom Bihl,  who had been convicted of  misusing public money.  Bihl hasn’t announced what his position on same sex marriage is,  but I would guess he’s “agin’ it.”
 Johnson may have a bright political future, not only  because he is gay,  but because he is bi-political, working both sides of the street, as he is on the Third Street controversy, and it doesn’t hurt that he is strongly in favor of gambling, which many locals believe will be the salvation of the city. 
       And what about “Governor” Johnson? Does that sound impossible? Well, so did “Governor” Strickland sound impossible twenty years ago, when he was teaching part-time evenings at Shawnee State University, and when a Republican member of the Cornerstone Church accused him of being sexually  involved with teen-age boys, without a shred of evidence, as I recall. I've heard Johnson was in Washington for Obama’s inauguration. He might even end up being the Republican candidate for governor. That day may arrive sooner than anyone can imagine. As Rob Portman’s conversion suggests, in spite of the  Tea Party, GOP could come to  stand not for the Grand Old Party but the Gay Old Party, which might be a big improvement.


From Kevin Johnsons Facebook pages


For  past posts related to the above post, click here   for “From Moses to David Malone,” and here for “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs.”









Monday, March 11, 2013

Third Street: Thick as Thieves


Third Street: Hatcherville



Third Street


      Shawnee State University doesn’t have a master plan as much as a master plot. By plot I mean not “a measured area of land,” but rather “a secret plan, a scheme.” The plot was to enrich a local lawyer, Clayton Johnson, and his partner in crime, a local developer, Neal Hatcher, by giving them sweetheart deals: for example,  taking  the worthless Marting Building off Johnson’s hands, for almost two million dollars, and allowing Hatcher  to build SSU student dormitories in a can’t-lose arrangement. Hatcher  built dormitories on the  northern side of Third Street, a major thoroughfare running through the heart of the university. The dormitories were on one side of Third Street, the classrooms, the administration buildings, the athletic center, the student center, etc., on the other. A hazardous arrangement. 
       Every student who lives in Hatcher’s dormitories plays Jeopardy. They have to to cross heavily trafficked Third Street day and  night, much of the traffic coming from or going to the Grant Bridge. Just the other day a young man from Portsmouth, on a moped,  was killed on the Kentucky side of the bridge, apparently by a driver who reportedly ran a red light. Like most streets in Portsmouth, Third Street speed limits are frequently violated, putting the lives and limbs of students in jeopardy. Now, the university wants to close Third Street and put grade school, middle school, and high school students, just north of Third Street, in jeopardy, making a bad situation even worse.
      Those who might be opposed to the project are dismissed, in a recent PDT editorial, (9 March 2013) as “people who are opposed to anything that brings progress.” Sound familiar? Steve Hayes has been peddling that line at WNXT for years. Where is Steve’s buddy, WSAZ’s Randy Yohe, now that the ruling clique could use Yohe’s support for closing Third Street? But the Can-Can Man was canned after being arrested for drunken driving. Of course, Yohe or no Yohe, the collection of bankrupts and political pawns who make up the Portsmouth City Council will pass the measure to close Third and probably quickly, as the PDT urges in the same editorial, as the council previously acted quickly to unload the Marting building on the taxpayers of Portsmouth. 
      If the most recent editor at the PDT did not support the closing of  Third Street,  it would not be long before he would join the long line of editors and reporters who have  quit or been fired when they failed to please the rich crooks who control the no-longer daily Daily Times  and the city. Now,  the politics are even thicker than they used to be. The Felix of the Odd Couple, Clayton Johnson, has retired, leaving Oscar, Neal Hatcher, holding the money bags alone, prompting Jeff Albrecht, Portsmouth’s preeminent snake oil salesman, to make his move for the Municipal Building, backed by the American Savings Bank in the person of Michael Gampp. Thick as thieves, they are all for closing Third Street, as quickly as possible, whatever the consequences. 


Click below for previous posts related to above post:


Thursday, February 28, 2013

Jesse Jackson, Jr.: Black or African-American?

Jesse Jackson, Jr., as I recollect him in Massie Hall


African-Americans may be  making a serious mistake in calling themselves black rather than African-American because in doing so they are opting for polarity rather than solidarity, for disparity rather than parity, for denigration rather than elevation. In the next census, the U.S. Census Bureau will be offering African-Americans the choice of identifying themselves as either African-Americans or blacks. (See the ABC news report at the end of this post.) I believe “black: is a mistake  because African-Americans cannot win the black-and-white name game. It is like a game of Scrabble in which they always get screwed. The Black is Beautiful slogan was an attempt to rebrand Negro. While it may have increased self-esteem on an conscious level, on an unconscious level, where the waters run very deep, Black is Beautiful  intensified the association between  blacks and badness.
Blacks are not really black and whites are not really white. We are all to some degree colored and will become increasingly so as racial barriers are further erased in America. By calling themselves black, African-Americans are burdening themselves with blame they don’t deserve. They are helping perpetuate the myth they are the white man’s burden, which too many so-called white Americans, continuing the South’s racist traditions, continue to think is the case.  In the minds of racists, in the North as well as the South, the West as well as the East, and also here in the Midwest, America’s so-called heartland, “blacks” are  associated with indolence, thriftlessness, and chitlins, with illegitimacy, crime, and dependency—dependency on both illegal drugs and the so-called welfare state.
Sometime in the mid-1990’s, in a February Black History Month conference at Shawnee State University, Jesse Jackson spoke to  a small gathering in a Massie Hall classroom. Jackson was in the front of the class, conservatively dressed in suit and tie,  sitting at a desk facing the audience. When he finished with his prepared remarks,  an  African-American  girl, who looked to be of high school age,  asked  him what he thought the appropriate name for people of their race should be.  She didn’t list them, but the options were colored, African-American, black, and, though it had fallen into disfavor,  Negro. The reason the word Negro had fallen into  disfavor was because the racist epithet “nigger” was probably derived from it. Negro  was pronounced “Niggra”  in the slave South and that evolved into  ‘nigger,” with all its hostile, racist connotations. Jackson  answered the  girl’s question without hesitation or qualification. He said he was certain of one thing: he didn’t want to be called black. “Look black up in the dictionary,” I recall him saying.  “Just see what it says—most of it’s bad and negative.”

Blackguards and Blacks

      We are heir to the Judaic-Christian tradition in which darkness is the primary metaphor for  what is undesirable, if not evil.  In Genesis we are told that “darkness was on the face of the deep,” so God said, “Let there be light: and there was light.” And since light was good, “God divided the light from the darkness.” God created a segregated world in which light and darkness were separate and opposite: God and the devil, good and evil, light and darkness.  Calvinists, among the most pessimistic of Christians,  had a frightening sense of what Herman Melville called “the power of blackness,” meaning the  power of evil. For Calvinists, as well as other Christians, the devil was a black. Merriam-Webster includes, among other definitions of black, the following: “dirty, soiled; characterized by the absence of light; thoroughly sinister or evil: wicked; very sad, gloomy or calamitous; marked by the occurrence of disaster; characterized by hostility or angry discontent: sullen; indicative of condemnation or discredit; connected with or invoking the supernatural and especially the devil.”  Could any name they might have chosen for their race be worse than the word black? Invariably, black is bad, either alone or combined with another word. Take the word  blackguard for example. Originally, a blackguard was  lower-class employee in an upper-class  British household who worked “downstairs,” in the kitchen, and guarded, figuratively if not literally,  the blackened instruments—the pots, pans, and ironware of the household. Blackguards were the bottom dwellers, doing the dirty work  in an upstairs-downstairs, class-rigid world. But, though bottom dwellers, they were nevertheless white and of the same race as their masters. But  just as the neutral word Negro evolved into nigger,  blackguard, i.e., a kitchen helper, because of its association with blackness, came to mean a “bad person.” The online dictionary Wordnik, defines blackguard as  “black in color of the skin or dress, or in character.” So, blackguard, which started out as a word reflecting class antagonism became a word reflecting racial antagonism.

Denigration as Defamation

      The word denigrate is also instructive. The Merriam-Webster definition of it is, literally, to blacken and, more figuratively, to defame or belittle. To create a neologism, denigrate means  “to negrify,” though those who use it are rarely aware of this meaning. African-Americans are more likely than whites to be aware of its racist connotations. In responding to a posting by a someone in a thread on Firedoglake, an African-American, objected to someone else’s use of denigration in a thread: “if you’re  black, can you please stop using the term ‘denigrate’ in this discussion?” he wrote. “i’m black too, friend. i say ‘ouch’ every time i read it . . .” The unintended irony in the following examples of the use of the word denigrate, compiled by Wordnik, speak for themselves: “We do not intend to denigrate southern values,” someone claimed. Denigrate  southern values? Negrify southern values? That is not what the user intended but given the racist etymology of the word, that is the absurd meaning of the statement. Here is another example Wordnik provides of the use of denigrate, which is even more absurd than the previous one:  “Some Rousseauean anthropologists protest that reports of cannibalism represent a racist desire to denigrate other cultures . . .” If instead of “to denigrate” the statement had read to defame, degrade, or impugn, then there would be no contradiction.  But to speak of denigrating  dark-skinned cultures by calling them cannibalistic is nonsense. It is like the pot calling the kettle black. These examples suggest that African-Americans cannot escape the stigma of blackness that is built into the English language.
Even a word that has nothing to do with black, such as  “niggardly,” which means parsimonious or stingy, should be avoided,  as the white aide to the  black mayor of the District of Columbia  discovered in 1999 when he characterized a stringent  D.C. budget as “niggardly.” Unlike the word Negro, niggardly has no etymological connection to nigger, but niggardly, a nearly obsolete word, sounds too much like it. There was a protest from blacks (as opposed, say,  from  African-Americans), and the white  aide, who was gay,  was fired but then rehired when the gay community protested on his behalf. The aide took it in stride, saying he had learned an important lesson. “I used to think it would be great if we could all be colorblind,” he said. “That’s naïve, especially for a white person, because a white person can afford to be colorblind. They don’t have to think about race every day. An African American does.”  In using the term African-American rather than black to refer to people of color, was the gay aide aware  that “black” was the racist equivalent of such sexist words as “queer,” “faggot,” and “fairy ” for the male homosexual?
Unfortunately, Jesse Jackson, Jr., did not practice what he preached in the classroom in Massie Hall. In the end he personified some of  the  negative meanings of the word black. If he didn’t turn out to be “thoroughly sinister or evil,” he did  prove to be deserving  of “condemnation or discredit.” He showed himself to be corrupt, selfish, dishonest, unprincipled, adulterous, hypocritical, conniving, spoiled, and materialistic. Though he didn’t want to be called black, he blackened the reputation of the race he was identified with, reinforcing racist stereotypes.

Blacks and African-Americans 

      But what  Jackson’s career really reflects poorly  on is not any particular race but on politicians in general. Politicians to a large extent are an embarrassment, not just to our nation,  but to our species, as is depressingly evident not only in Chicago and Washington but also in Portsmouth.  In some respects, specifically the degree of audacity, Portsmouth may be worse than Chicago and Washington, in part because the major papers in those cities, The Chicago Tribune and The Washington Post, occasionally do investigative journalism, while The Portsmouth Daily Times has almost always been under the thumb of the crooks who control the city. Not even in Chicago or Washington would  a notorious blackguard, a white  drug-dealing pimp be brazenly appointed to fill a vacated elective office without a peep from anybody, especially not from local law enforcement and  the local media.  At least in Chicago and Washington the crooks occasionally get publicized, arrested, and jailed. In Portsmouth they get away with everything but murder.  In Portsmouth we had not only a drug dealing pimp being appointed to city  council we have a philandering, hypocritical, homophobic unelected mayor who just coincidentally  happens to be black.
Bill Clinton is jokingly said to have been the first black president. There is some truth to the joke, but it is not a flattering truth. Americans should be grateful that in 2008 they elected and in 2012 reelected not the first black—as Jesse Jackson Sr., was grooming Jesse Jackson,Jr., to be—but the  first  African-American president. Jesse Jackson, Jr.’s, father  was speaking not as an African-American but as a black when he was overheard saying  about Obama, on a mike he didn’t realize was on, “I’d like to cut his nuts off.”  Jackson, Sr., was reportedly angry at Obama for speaking down to blacks. But what the president was actually doing was speaking up for African-Americans. 





The form that was used in the last US census.












Wednesday, February 20, 2013

The Illustrated Ballad of Dr. Lundeen




Now that the Tenth Appellate District Court has upheld the revocation of Dr. James Lundeen's medical license, I call the attention of those have not read it to my post "The Illustrated Ballad of Dr. Lundeen." (Click on  the link below.)


http://rivervices.blogspot.com/2011/12/illustrated-ballad-of-dr-lundeen.html





Wednesday, February 13, 2013

OH EPA: Death by Chocolate, Death by Power Point

Jane Murray addressing panel at EPA meeting following stultifying
 Power Point presentation by Richard Duncan, on stage left


In Flohr Hall of Clark Memorial Library at Shawnee State University, on  the evening of  February 12, 2013, the Ohio EPA sponsored an Information Session and a Public Hearing regarding the draft agreement  reached between the Ohio EPA and the city of Portsmouth. In a display of bureaucratese,  somebody in government had named this kind of  agreement “Administrative Order of Content.” One of the aims of bureaucratese, as this name illustrates, is to keep the public in the dark about what is going on. The AOC in question, to use its acronym, has to do with water. When it comes to two extremely important  resources, namely water and money, Portsmouth city government has played fast and loose with state and federal laws and ordinances that are supposed to  regulate them. 
The Information part of the EPA evening, which took up the first hour, consisted almost entirely of a deadly dull Power Point presentation by Richard Duncan, the city’s man in charge of sewers. Duncan’s Power Point presentation had as one of its results, intended or not, the paralysis of most of the forty or so members of the public and city government in attendance.  Just as spiders paralyze the  insects that fall into their webs, preserving them for future consumption, Duncan with his mumbling delivery, faded slides, and hypnotic red laser pointer, rendered the audience stultified for the second hour of the meeting, the so-called Public Hearing half of the evening, during which the audience was allowed to  ask questions about the “information” that Duncan had provided in his Power Point presentation. However, when Duncan finished and the  moderator asked for questions,  there were none.  Tick, tick, tick. She waited and she waited. How embarrassing. It was like asking the paralyzed insects trapped in a spider web if they had any questions about the spider’s slide show. Finally, to  everyone’s relief, somebody finally came forward and asked a question.
Emboldened by that hearty soul, I volunteered to ask a question,  but as I approached  the microphone at the front of the hall  my foot was asleep and so was my cobwebby  brain.  I asked the panel about  subhead sections F and G on page 4 of  the draft agreement. The “Respondent” referred to at the beginning of F is the city of Portsmouth or its chief officer, the mayor. However, although Portsmouth Mayor Unelect   David Malone was in the audience he took no part in the proceedings and asked no questions, leaving Duncan to twist in the wind. The question I asked the panel on stage was how come there was no mention during the Information hour  of  the important statement in the agreement that charged the  Respondent (the city)  with repeated violations of the Sciotoville and Portsmouth  permits governing the city’s handling of  sewage water and storm water, and the violation by the city of  the  requirements of Section 301 of the Clean Water Act, the federal law governing polluted water throughout the United States. What follows is a  photocopy of the section of the agreement I am alluding to:

From the draft agreement between OH EPA and city of Portsmouth


           It was Duncan who answered my question why the charges against the city (and him principally) had not been mentioned. He said the part of the draft agreement I referred to was “boilerplate” language and didn’t really mean much. His answer like his Power Point presentation was an effort to deceive and obfuscate. The Respondent referred in F of page 4 of the draft agreement is not just anybody or any city; it applies specifically to Portsmouth, which a number of times, during storms, had discharged raw sewage into the Ohio River. I asked the panel if they agreed with Duncan that it was boilerplate language and didn’t really mean much. The EPA representative, Barbara VanTil,  sitting immediately to Duncan’s left on the panel nodded her head in agreement with him and murmured “Yes.” Her response was a revelation to me. I have always assumed the acronym EPA stood for Environment Protection Agency. I did not know it also meant Egregious Protection of Assholes. What Ms. VanTil’s response and the meeting itself revealed to me was the  likelihood that the city’s chronic sewer crisis is the result not just of the incompetence and dishonesty of politicians of Portsmouth but of the enabling of the good folks at the EPA at both the state and federal levels. They are, knowledgeable, polite, and even sweet, like chocolate, but they are also the kiss of death, like Duncan’s toxic Power Point presentation. Just today PBS released a report by the Center for Public Integrity, with the title “EPA Contaminated by Conflict of Interest” (click here.) That appeared to be the case at the meeting OH EPA hosted last evening in Portsmouth.
It must be very difficult to work for an agency like the EPA in a swing state like Ohio. In very red or very blue state, you would know where you stand. But in a swing state like Ohio, half blue and half red, the politics of environmental protection are as polluted as the sewers of Portsmouth.  I suspect that OH EPA is constantly trying to avoid getting caught in the middle, to avoid controversy and, consequently, by not taking a stand, they become enablers. The water controversy has drug on for years, as they say in southern Ohio, and will probably drag on, unresolved,  for many years more, as the OH EPA enables  as it waffles.
It’s the same with money. While the state auditor in Ohio dilly dallies the crooked politicians in Portsmouth channel money that is supposed to be used for road, bridges, and sewers to increase their own salaries and the salaries and benefits of the public employees who strongly support them. It’s the same with water. Instead of taking decisive action, the EPA treads water, enabling incompetent city employees like Duncan to discharge raw sewage into the Ohio and paralyze attendees at EPA public meetings with stultifying  Power Point presentations.  It is no wonder city politicians privately express contempt for the toothless state regulatory agencies. If former mayor Jane Murray and councilman Steve Sturgill had not been at the meeting, challenging the bureaucratese and the raw sewage,  the rest of us might still be sitting in Flohr Hall, paralyzed by  Duncan’s Power Point presentation.


. . . the rest of us might still be sitting in Flohr Hall, paralyzed by  Duncan’s Power Point presentation.